Skip to search.

Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest.

×Close this window

rouesolaire · rouesolaire@yahoo.fr | Group Member  - Edit Membership Start a Group | My Groups
evola_as_he_is · EVOLA AS HE IS

The Yahoo! Groups Product Blog

Check it out!

Group Information

  • Members: 121
  • Category: Spirituality
  • Founded: Nov 19, 2004
  • Language: English

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Message search is now enhanced, find messages faster. Take it for a spin.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Mussolini's Intellectuals   Topic List   < Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Reply  | 
Re: [evola_as_he_is] Mussolini's Intellectuals

--- savitar_devi <savitar_devi@...> wrote:

> The portrayal of Evola is this book is quite rancid
> to say the least…
> this is a quote from the preface, and follows in the
> actual book is
> considerably worse. To say that the author holds
> Evola in low esteem
> would be a massive understatement.

I have not read "Mussolini's Intellectuals" yet, but
its author, A. James Gregor (who has been writing
studies of Fascism for about forty years now), has
discussed Evola before, such as in his book "Phoenix"
which was published in 1999. In that book, it's not
that he holds Evola in low esteem, but rather that he
takes other historians to task for thinking that
anything useful can be gleaned from studying Evola in
terms of understanding Fascism as a historical
phenomenon, as has become the trend in recent
scholarship on Fascism (such as in the writings of
Roger Griffin). Some historians, including Griffin,
Stanley Payne and George Mosse, have been looking to
define what they term "generic fascism" or the
"fascist minimum," which they believe to be the
universal characteristics which all fascist movements
- whether it is German National Socialism, Italian
Fascism, Spanish Falangism, the Hungarian Arrow Cross,
Oswald Mosley's BUF, GRECE, the American Nazi Party,
etc. - share. Gregor is of the opinion that such
classifications are reductive and do not shed any
light on understanding any of these phenomena, each of
which he believes can better be understood within
their specific historical and sociological contexts.
His problem with Evola in this context is that some
historians have begun using him (among other names) in
an effort to show a link between the original fascist
movements and their many post-war offshoots, and have
begun implying that Evola was influential in
establishing a continuity between historical fascism
and the present-day manifestations of the Right. I
don't think that Gregor is necessarily wrong. While it
has been documented that Evola had links to both
Italian Fascism and the SS, I've never seen it
demonstrated that he had any significant impact on
either movement. The one claim that I've seen somewhat
substantiated is that his ideas on race as a spiritual
rather than solely a biological category were
influential on Mussolini when he was seeking an
alternative to Nazi race theory, but even here, from
what I've read Evola was only one of several thinkers
to apply himself to this task. So, from a historians'
point of view, I can see why Gregor would think that
it is wrongheaded to try to understand historical
Fascism as an Evolian phenomenon. And I don't think
that most readers of Evola today would find fault with
this view, since, clearly, Fascism and National
Socialism would have been much more successful in the
long run had they adhered to a more Traditional
world-view.

At any rate, I am curious to read this book and see
what Gregor has to say. I don't think it is so much a
matter of Evola-bashing as much as an attempt to
reframe the historians' debate about Evola's role in
events.



__________________________________
Yahoo! FareChase: Search multiple travel sites in one click.
http://farechase.yahoo.com





Fri Nov 4, 2005 6:02 pm

ouro_boros
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email
 | 
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Has anyone come across A. J. Gregors' book `Mussolini's Intellectuals'? The portrayal of Evola is this book is quite rancid to say the least… this is a quote...
savitar_devi Offline Send Email Nov 4, 2005
10:00 am

Sure. In the meantime, this is a description of the book : "Fascism has traditionally been characterized as irrational and anti- intellectual, finding...
evola_as_he_is Offline Send Email Nov 4, 2005
10:17 am

... I have not read "Mussolini's Intellectuals" yet, but its author, A. James Gregor (who has been writing studies of Fascism for about forty years now), has ...
Michael Lord
ouro_boros Offline Send Email
Nov 4, 2005
6:19 pm

By 1925, Evola was attempting to resolve the problems of philosophical idealism by pursuing epistemological problems into ontological conclusions that made the...
Savitar Devi
savitar_devi Offline Send Email
Nov 5, 2005
11:15 am

Lately, a message has been posted on the forum of the site www.juliusevola.it by a former student of Piero di Vona, one of the foremost experts on Evola's...
evola_as_he_is Offline Send Email Nov 6, 2005
1:01 pm

Alas, Gregor does provide references to some of his less flattering descriptions. The ‘hysterical fanatic’ slur has two footnotes relating to it – ...
Savitar Devi
savitar_devi Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2005
9:33 am

Gregor didn't write "Montini recognized Evola as just that kind of anticlerical "hysterical fanatic" who could best serve his purpose...", but "Mussolini...
evola_as_he_is Offline Send Email Nov 7, 2005
11:52 am

But if Evola was universally viewed as a mere pipsqueak, how could he have either put the mighty Vatican on the defensive, or deceived the multitudinous Nazi...
Rowan Berkeley
rowan_berkeley Offline Send Email
Nov 5, 2005
12:51 pm

In the most recent edition of 'Imperialismo pagano' (Edizioni Mediterranee, 2004), De Turris quotes a few excerpts from a text by Yvon de Bergnac called...
evola_as_he_is Offline Send Email Nov 5, 2005
1:55 pm

... Post-modern smugness!...
Pluto Gordon
specialediti... Offline Send Email
Nov 5, 2005
8:13 pm

Note that Mussolini, talking of Evola, call him "il professor Julius Evola". Knowing the aversion of Evola for the academical titles and for the intellectuals...
vandermok
charltonroad36 Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2005
12:59 pm

Before we get too subtle here, note that Mussolini was a former primary school teacher. ... Evola". Knowing the aversion of Evola for the academical titles and...
evola_as_he_is Offline Send Email Nov 7, 2005
1:12 pm

Copyright © 2012 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Copyright Policy - Guidelines NEW - Help